After a fun-filled summer at camp, Liberty returns home to a surprise: her mother's fiancé, the alluring and mysterious John Smith. As the awkward 16-year-old navigates her new reality, she soon realizes Mr. Smith is too good to be true. With every perfect piece of him, Liberty unravels the secrets of his past, leading the teenager to uncover a web of deceit and a mystery that threatens to unravel her own family. But when Liberty goes too far, she has to decide whether the truth is worth losing the love and security she's been searching for.