One year after Winnie managed to save her quiet town on Christmas Eve, she finds herself wishing she'd never been born. But her wish comes true, and Winnie is magically transported to a twisted parallel universe backwards version of her own town. She quickly discovers that this universe is a nightmare come true with a murderous maniac terrorizing the town. Determined not to let her new parallel self become a victim, Winnie teams up with a misfit parallel version of her own friend to identify the culprit and find her way back to her regular life.